Independent scores. No brand can pay for a better one.
Cradle Score
Pacifiers

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother

BudgetChecked Sep 30, 20263 sources

Our take

One-piece food-grade silicone in fun colors, dishwasher safe, and passed Consumer Reports' tests.

One-pieceFood-grade siliconeDishwasher safe

Consider instead: Avent Soothie for hospital familiarity.

Before you buy

Do you need it?Nice to have Many babies find them soothing, and the AAP notes a pacifier at sleep time is linked to lower SIDS risk. Some babies refuse them entirely.
Secondhand?Buy new. Buy new and replace any that crack or tear.
TipBabies have strong preferences. Try a couple of shapes before buying multipacks.

What parents and testers say

Recurring praise

  • Easy to clean
  • Cute options

Recurring complaints

  • Few reported downsides

Our summary of patterns across the reviews and threads linked below, not quotes.

Materials & safety check

2 of 2 checks clear.

Lab testsPassed Consumer Reports' lead, phthalate, nitrosamine and bite tests
RecallsNone found in CPSC pacifier recalls since 2020

When to buy it

Registry

Add 2-3 shapes; babies have preferences

After birth

If breastfeeding, many wait until feeding is established

Ongoing

Replace at any tear or stickiness; never tie to a cord

Other pacifiers we scored

See all pacifiers →
89+5 pts

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

About $2 each · Excellent

84Same

MAM Original Matte Pacifier

Budget · Good

Own this? Tell us how it's going

Reports from parents who've used a product for months are the hardest thing to find. Yours goes only to our team and helps keep this score honest. It isn't published.

How do you feel about it?

Common questions

Is the Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother non-toxic?

There's no legal definition of "non-toxic" for baby products, so here's what we checked. Lab tests: Passed Consumer Reports' lead, phthalate, nitrosamine and bite tests. Recalls: None found in CPSC pacifier recalls since 2020. It scores 84 out of 100 on materials and safety, and 84 overall.

Not sure what a label means? See baby product labels, explained.

Sources

  1. Consumer Reports: Best pacifiers based on lead, phthalate and durability testsconsumerreports.org
  2. Mommyhood101: Best pacifiers of 2026, testedmommyhood101.com
  3. CPSC recall database: "pacifier" recalls since 2020saferproducts.gov
Spot an error or something out of date?