Independent scores. No brand can pay for a better one.
Cradle Score
Teethers

Skip Hop Sesame Street Elmo Silicone Teether

VariesChecked Sep 30, 20262 sources

Our take

Why there's no score

Recalled Sep 3, 2026: the black eyes can come off if the teether is frozen, posing a choking hazard. Stop using it and contact Skip Hop for a refund.

Recalled September 3, 2026: Elmo's black eyes can detach if the teether is frozen, which is a choking hazard.

Recall: Sep 3, 2026

Consider instead: Itzy Ritzy or Mombella teethers.

What parents and testers say

Recurring praise

  • Popular character design

Recurring complaints

  • Recalled for detaching eyes

Our summary of patterns across the reviews and threads linked below, not quotes.

Materials & safety check

0 of 1 checks clear, 1 to know about.

RecallSep 3, 2026: eyes can detach when frozen; choking hazard

When to buy it

Registry

Optional

~4-6 months

Teething usually starts; chill, don't freeze

Ongoing

Inspect for cracks and replace

Other teethers we scored

See all teethers →

Common questions

Is the Skip Hop Sesame Street Elmo Silicone Teether non-toxic?

Skip Hop Sesame Street Elmo Silicone Teether has a safety warning, so we don't score it. There's no legal definition of "non-toxic" for baby products, so here's what we checked. Recall: Sep 3, 2026: eyes can detach when frozen; choking hazard.

Not sure what a label means? See baby product labels, explained.

Sources

  1. CPSC recall database: "teether" recalls since 2022saferproducts.gov
  2. Consumer Reports: Baby product recalls in 2026consumerreports.org
Spot an error or something out of date?