Independent scores. No brand can pay for a better one.
Cradle Score
Cribs

Carter's by DaVinci Colby 4-in-1 Convertible Crib

About $249Checked Sep 30, 20262 sources

Our take

Best value: solid pine, GREENGUARD Gold, the easiest assembly of tested cribs, and a great mattress fit.

GREENGUARD GoldSolid pine4 heights~$249

Consider instead: Babyletto Hudson for an included toddler rail.

Before you buy

Do you need it?Must-have A crib is the long-term safe sleep space, and a convertible model can become a toddler bed.
Cost per monthAbout $6.92 a month over a typical 36 months of use. Our estimate; your use may be shorter or longer.
Secondhand?Secondhand with checks. Only if it was made after June 2011, when the current federal crib standard took effect, and has all its original hardware. Never use a drop-side crib.

What parents and testers say

Recurring praise

  • Most affordable certified pick
  • Easy assembly
  • Excellent mattress fit

Recurring complaints

  • Softer wood dents
  • Conversion parts sold separately

Our summary of patterns across the reviews and threads linked below, not quotes.

Materials & safety check

2 of 2 checks clear.

EmissionsGREENGUARD Gold certified
RecallsNone found in CPSC crib recalls since 2019

When to buy it

Registry

Add it early so it arrives before the third trimester ends

By 36 weeks

Set it up and wash anything fabric

Months 4-6

Plan the next stage: crib, sleep sack or bigger size

Other cribs we scored

See all cribs →
86+2 pts

Babyletto Yuzu 8-in-1 Convertible Crib

Premium · Excellent

85+1 pts

Delta Children Frankie 4-in-1 Convertible Crib

About $189 · Excellent

Head-to-head

Own this? Tell us how it's going

Reports from parents who've used a product for months are the hardest thing to find. Yours goes only to our team and helps keep this score honest. It isn't published.

How do you feel about it?

Sources

  1. BabyGearLab: The best cribsbabygearlab.com
  2. CPSC recall database: "crib" recalls since 2019saferproducts.gov
Spot an error or something out of date?