Independent scores. No brand can pay for a better one.
Cradle Score
Crib mattresses

Emily Organic Crib Mattress

About $299Checked Sep 30, 20262 sources

Our take

Certified-organic coir, wool and cotton over an innerspring at a mid-range price. It has one firmness on both sides and needs a separate waterproof protector.

GOTS + GOLSGREENGUARD GoldInnerspring + coirShips flat

Consider instead: Naturepedic if you want waterproofing built in.

Before you buy

Do you need it?Must-have Every crib needs a firm, flat mattress that fits snugly. A two-stage mattress carries over into the toddler years.
Cost per monthAbout $8.31 a month over a typical 36 months of use. Our estimate; your use may be shorter or longer.
Cheaper optionBabyletto Pure Core Non-Toxic Crib Mattress: About $199, scored 81 (Good).
Secondhand?Buy new. Buy new. Firmness and a snug fit matter for safe sleep, and a used mattress can sag or have an unknown history.

What parents and testers say

Recurring praise

  • Organic materials throughout
  • Good edge support
  • Strong value for an organic mattress

Recurring complaints

  • No dual-firmness toddler side
  • Needs a separate waterproof protector

Our summary of patterns across the reviews and threads linked below, not quotes.

Materials & safety check

3 of 4 checks clear, 1 to know about.

CertificationsGOTS, GOLS and GREENGUARD Gold
Flame retardantsNone used
WaterproofingNone built in; add an organic protector
RecallsNone found in CPSC crib recalls since 2019

When to buy it

Registry

Add it early so it arrives before the third trimester ends

By 36 weeks

Set it up and wash anything fabric

Months 4-6

Plan the next stage: crib, sleep sack or bigger size

Other crib mattresses we scored

See all crib mattresses →

Own this? Tell us how it's going

Reports from parents who've used a product for months are the hardest thing to find. Yours goes only to our team and helps keep this score honest. It isn't published.

How do you feel about it?

Common questions

Are Emily Organic Crib Mattress non-toxic?

There's no legal definition of "non-toxic" for baby products, so here's what we checked. Certifications: GOTS, GOLS and GREENGUARD Gold. Flame retardants: None used. Waterproofing: None built in; add an organic protector. Recalls: None found in CPSC crib recalls since 2019. It scores 92 out of 100 on materials and safety, and 87 overall.

Not sure what a label means? See baby product labels, explained.

Sources

  1. Mommyhood101: Best crib mattresses of 2026, testedmommyhood101.com
  2. CPSC recall database: "crib" recalls since 2019saferproducts.gov
Spot an error or something out of date?