Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier vs MAM Original Matte Pacifier
Avent Soothie scores higher overall: 89 vs 84. See all pacifiers ranked.
- Materials & safety: Avent Soothie (84 vs 82)
- Parent consensus: Avent Soothie (90 vs 82)
- Value & longevity: Avent Soothie (96 vs 90)
The one-piece hospital pacifier: cheap, easy to sterilize and low on nipple confusion. It can trap water after boiling and pops out as babies get stronger.
To know: Hygiene: Can retain water after boiling; shake dry
Full Avent Soothie review →Symmetrical silicone nipple with an anti-slip surface and a sterilizer case. Passed every Consumer Reports test.
All 2 materials and safety checks clear.
Full MAM Original review →Which should you choose?
Choose Avent Soothie if you want
- Trusted and cheap
- Easy to sterilize
Trade-off: Retains water after boiling
Choose MAM Original if you want
- Any orientation works
- Gentle shield
Trade-off: Few reported downsides
Questions parents ask
Which is better, Avent Soothie or MAM Original?
Avent Soothie scores higher overall: 89 vs 84. Avent Soothie: The one-piece hospital pacifier: cheap, easy to sterilize and low on nipple confusion. MAM Original: Symmetrical silicone nipple with an anti-slip surface and a sterilizer case.
Which has better materials and safety, Avent Soothie or MAM Original?
Avent Soothie scores higher on materials and safety (84 vs 82). Both pages list each check and its source.
Which do parents prefer, Avent Soothie or MAM Original?
Avent Soothie has stronger parent and tester consensus (90 vs 82). Top praise for Avent Soothie: Trusted and cheap. For MAM Original: Any orientation works.
Which is the better value, Avent Soothie or MAM Original?
Avent Soothie scores higher on value and longevity (96 vs 90). Prices: Avent Soothie About $2 each, MAM Original Budget.
Want a different matchup? Open these two in the compare tool and add a third.