Spectra S1 Double Electric Breast Pump vs Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow
Spectra S1 scores higher overall: 89 vs 84. See all breast pumps ranked.
- Materials & safety: Spectra S1 (84 vs 80)
- Parent consensus: Spectra S1 (92 vs 86)
- Value & longevity: Spectra S1 (92 vs 88)
Testers' best overall pump: powerful, quiet, rechargeable and very adjustable.
All 2 materials and safety checks clear.
Full Spectra S1 review →A reliable, powerful double pump that comes with a tote and cooler. Fewer settings than Spectra.
All 1 materials and safety checks clear.
Full Medela Pump in Style review →Which should you choose?
Choose Spectra S1 if you want
- Powerful and quiet
- Great battery life
- Lots of adjustment
Trade-off: Parts harder to find in stores
Choose Medela Pump in Style if you want
- Powerful, efficient
- Includes cooler
- Multiple shield sizes
Trade-off: Single speed/suction dial
Questions parents ask
Which is better, Spectra S1 or Medela Pump in Style?
Spectra S1 scores higher overall: 89 vs 84. Spectra S1: Testers' best overall pump: powerful, quiet, rechargeable and very adjustable. Medela Pump in Style: A reliable, powerful double pump that comes with a tote and cooler.
Which has better materials and safety, Spectra S1 or Medela Pump in Style?
Spectra S1 scores higher on materials and safety (84 vs 80). Both pages list each check and its source.
Which do parents prefer, Spectra S1 or Medela Pump in Style?
Spectra S1 has stronger parent and tester consensus (92 vs 86). Top praise for Spectra S1: Powerful and quiet. For Medela Pump in Style: Powerful, efficient.
Which is the better value, Spectra S1 or Medela Pump in Style?
Spectra S1 scores higher on value and longevity (92 vs 88). Prices: Spectra S1 Varies, Medela Pump in Style Varies.
Want a different matchup? Open these two in the compare tool and add a third.